Encouraging Private Sector Participation



Introduction

Most reform and restructuring efforts aim to increase railways commercial orientation and reduce government direction and support of the sector. Governments worldwide have reformed state railway departments and agencies in an effort to reduce costs, improve services, and realize more effective investments. Revitalizing rail transport takes fresh approaches and often requires large capital infusions. Encouraging private sector participation is a dual-purpose strategy that seeks not only investors but also private sector operators, whose experience and skills can sharpen the commercial focus of railway enterprises.

The private sector has much to offer railway reform efforts—capital is more abundant in the private sector and investors recognize that railways can offer opportunities for good returns. Private enterprises are driven by commercially oriented managers focusing on factors that affect profit and loss—marketing, customer service, and controlling costs. These factors are not typically the focus of state managers.

Private sector participation is not a panacea for reforming government-run railways. Governments with an ineffective and expensive rail sector have to decide whether to fix the railway first (corporatize, downsize staff, make key investments), or to let the private sector carry out the fixes. Even before reform efforts begin, governments need to do the following:

  1. Clarify their objectives, which might include the need to: (i) reduce subsidies; (ii) seek relief from ongoing investment needs; and (iii) provide more and better services.

  2. Understand how these objectives might be achieved, for example: (i) improve productivity and efficiency; (ii) reduce services and close branches; (iii) find private investors.

  3. Understand the political implications of required actions, for example: (i) large reductions in the workforce; (ii) reductions in the scope of loss-making services; (iii) greater pricing flexibility; and (iv) internal unit restructuring.

Probably the most important of these is to clarify and define the objectives they seek — the Why of reforms. Once these steps are taken, governments can examine areas that may still require subsidy, and determine how that subsidy should be structured. Although private sector participation is part of the solution to many railway problems, the process is usually prolonged and requires careful structuring to facilitate private investors’ due diligence, risk assessment, and eventual participation. Some possible ways for the private sector to participate in railways are discussed in the next part.

    
Copyright ©  The World Bank. All Rights Reserved.